How to Hire a Accountant
Accountants are the guardians of financial accuracy and compliance. Whether you're hiring for a startup's first finance hire or a mid-market controller, the right accountant brings technical rigor, process discipline, and the judgment to navigate ambiguity. This guide covers what great accountants look like and how to hire them.
What to Look For
- Technical accounting knowledge: GAAP/IFRS, month-end close, reconciliations
- Software proficiency: QuickBooks, NetSuite, Xero, or your accounting platform
- Audit experience or comfort with audit preparation — critical for funded or public companies
- Attention to detail combined with efficiency: accuracy at scale, not just accuracy on a single entry
- Process improvement instincts: the best accountants automate and standardize
- Tax and regulatory awareness appropriate to your jurisdiction and entity type
The Hiring Process
- 1
Technical accounting screen
Cover journal entries, month-end close process, and reconciliations. Use concrete scenarios.
- 2
Software and tools assessment
Ask about their proficiency with your specific accounting stack. A practical test is fine for critical systems.
- 3
Process and judgment interview
Give a realistic scenario: how do they handle a discrepancy discovered during close? How do they prioritize competing deadlines?
- 4
Reference checks
Talk to former managers about accuracy, reliability, and how they handle pressure during audit or close.
Interview Tips
- Ask 'Walk me through your month-end close process at your last company' — reveals organization and rigor
- Give a scenario with a journal entry error discovered after books are closed — how do they handle it?
- Ask how they've improved a process or reduced the time for a close cycle
- Probe on audit experience: 'What's the most challenging audit request you've responded to?'
Red Flags
- Can't explain the difference between cash and accrual accounting
- No experience with reconciliations or month-end close
- Inconsistent accuracy in their own application materials
- Uncomfortable discussing audit preparation
- Rigid about 'this is how I've always done it' — modern accounting requires adapting to new tools
Interview Accountant Candidates with AI at Your Side
Get structured interview questions suggested in real-time. Focus on the candidate, not on your notes.